McGraw recalls that he dropped to his knees onstage after one of Hill's performances and said, "I'm really serious. I want you to marry me."
When he came offstage after his own performance, Hill had written a message on his mirror reading, "Yes, I'm gonna be your wife! I love you," with a Sharpie pen. This was on June 26, 1996, and they were married only months later in Rayville, La.
McGraw says he still has that mirror to this day, after 30 years of marriage.